'To the Wonder' (2013) Movie Review

To the Wonder Movie Review
Ben Affleck and Rachel McAdams in To the Wonder
NOTE: This review was first published on September 12, 2012 after I saw it at the 2012 Toronto Film Festival. I am reposting it today as it opens in limited theaters this weekend.

Terrence Malick's To the Wonder is The Tree of Life 2 though on a much smaller scale. It's also what appears to be a signal Malick is no longer interested in traditional narratives. While the story is told in a linear fashion, I'd be shocked if more than 10-percent of it contained dialogue that wasn't voice over and the number of shots focused on water and the distant sun on the horizon have to fill almost half the picture. I say none of this as an all-encompassing complaint, merely an indicator of what you're in for.

To the Wonder
Grade: C+

To the Wonder"To the Wonder" is a Magnolia Pictures release, directed by Terrence Malick and is rated R for some sexuality/nudity.

The cast includes Ben Affleck, Javier Bardem, Rachel McAdams, Olga Kurylenko and Jessica Chastain.

Cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki once again captures the sun-kissed world the same as he did in Tree of Life and, as expected, it's beautiful, but is it also pointless? To the Wonder is filled with so many random shots of water, walking in wheat fields, twirling in the backyard and bedroom wrestling it's more of a 112-minute visual poem than it is a movie, told through the collective voices of its four main characters.

It's a menagerie of pretty images and narrative suggestions that allow the viewer to make of it what they will, big or small. The story can really "mean" anything, not the least of which being the search for God on an Earth that appears to be poisoned from within. Has God forsaken us?

The story is largely guided by the voice over from Olga Kurylenko and Javier Bardem, two characters out of their "element" as it were. Their voice over is in their native language and neither is happy with their surroundings. Kurylenko plays Marina, who's come to Oklahoma with her boyfriend, Neil (Ben Affleck), but upon arrival her daughter (Tatiana Chiline) isn't fitting in. Eventually, she returns to Paris and Neil begins a relationship with a local woman (Rachel McAdams).

Bardem, playing Father Quintana, has conversations with Marina before she decides to return home, but he too is lost and alone, searching throughout the entire film for what I initially presumed was a lost love, but soon came to realize he was searching for God. Searching for answers. His search takes him door-to-door while Neil's job has him testing ground samples where toxins have been found and residents complain of a black ooze rising from the cracks in their porch.

This is the playing field you have to work with. Certainly there is a bit more to it than I have revealed so as not to ruin the experience for you, but from a story perspective these are the roots. The characters wander aimlessly within this space as their voice over puts thoughts in our heads to accompany the images on screen. None of these thoughts are entirely clear, meant more as suggestions pointing you on an eventual path.

The most curious thing about the voice over, though, is Malick's decision to have the characters narrate the film in their native language. Kurylenko speaking in French, Bardem in Spanish and Affleck and McAdams in English. The official synopsis refers to Kurylenko and Bardem's characters as "exiles" living in America. Both wish to return to their native country, and who could blame them, considering the soil has not only been poisoned, but it's suggested so have the people and animals living there.

Is this a message aimed not at the Earth as a whole, but at the state of America today? There's certainly something to this as Malick's coverage of a grocery store treats it as an obvious example of excess as Marina's daughter marvels at its size. It's the second time we are made to look at closely at America, the first of which being the dramatic shift from the streets of Paris to the barren Oklahoma landscape. What it all means is for the audience to decide, I'm certainly feeling around in the dark for meaning.

This, however, is exactly what the film does. It presents nuggets of ideas and leaves them for you to interpret. I usually like this technique, but when it is this ambiguous and grey it becomes a little tiresome.

There's nothing to say regarding the performances unless smiling, gazing in the distance or seductive glances are considered acting. The actors are nothing more than pieces of Malick's landscape doing as he wishes. They are the pretty people in a world where the sun is eternally on the horizon, its rays glancing over a shoulder, between the leaves in a tree or through a hole in the fence.

The film gets its title from the medieval site of Mont Saint-Michel, nicknamed "The Wonder of the Western World". Located in Normandy, France, Marina and Neil visit this site in the film's opening moment. At the top stands a church and a statue of St. Michael the Archangel. The film's religious elements are unmistakable and it won't be the last time Malick returns to this location.

To the Wonder, upon reflection, is a film that melts into your mind and is impossible to forget due to its visuals. Instead of calling it a movie I would say it's more of a tone poem, a symphonic movement of visuals in 112 minutes. The mistake is to look at it as a movie and expect a compelling narrative. Whether it's compelling or not could be argued for hours.

Also, to say a film is poetic is often to jump to the conclusion that means it's great. For many To the Wonder will be great, they'll take more out of it than I did and for that I will be jealous. I can appreciate it for what it is, and discussing it was entertaining, but for as filled as it is with lush imagery, a lot of that imagery felt empty in meaning.


More Movie Reviews

'Straight Outta Compton' (2015) Movie ReviewB-

Straight Outta Compton (2015)

'Mistress America' (2015) Movie ReviewB+

Mistress America (2015)

'The Man from U.N.C.L.E.' (2015) Movie ReviewB

The Man From U.N.C.L.E. (2015)

'Cop Car' (2015) Movie ReviewB-

Cop Car (2015)

More Reviews
  • http://www.ropeofsilicon.com/profile/rusty/ rusty

    Love this review Brad. The last two paragraphs lead me to see the film myself on release in the UK earlier this year.

    It had been a busy old week in the office and frankly the West-end of London was getting me down! I was bored of the endless people and rushing and feeling hemmed in by the concrete of my surroundings.

    "To The Wonder" opened on the Friday of that week and was showing in one of my favourite old cinemas. It is an 1930's theatre, now owned by a chain, it's riddled with mice. But when I was in college I would go back week after week to see "Reservoir Dogs" before it was out on home video. (They showed it for months).

    Back to the point. I booked my ticket and strolled off that Friday. I'll be honest, thanks to your review, my expectations were simple, I want to immerse myself in beautiful images for two hours.

    I speak a little French and a tiny bit of Spanish, so I could just kick back and lose my self in this. It was beautiful and remains burned into my memories today.

    This was an entirely context driven screening and I couldn't repeat it regularly, but just at that time it worked for me.

    I think I was still smiling on Monday morning.

    Totally agree with your review. If had been looking for a solid narrative that evening, this would not have worked for me. It's certainly not "Badlands". But at that time, in that place it was just what I wanted!

    Thanks for indulging my insane ramblings. Just felt like sharing.

  • http://www.ropeofsilicon.com/profile/andyluvsfilms/ andyluvsfilms

    i loved this film, it helped seeing it on the big screen but i preferred it over Tree Of Life

  • http://www.criterion.com/my_criterion/27913-criterion10 Criterion10

    I doubt this will ever play near me, so I'll probably just have to rent it from on demand.

  • http://www.ropeofsilicon.com/profile/Winchester/ Winchester

    It's not that I wouldn't watch this film, it's just I feel I would have to be in a real specific frame of mind or mood to maybe appreciate it best. Which makes it really difficult to get a sense of when to try and do that.

  • http://www.ropeofsilicon.com/profile/Chris138/ Chris138

    Well, I've already shared my thoughts on this film elsewhere, but it's the first Malick film I didn't care for. Very disappointing. Hopefully his next one is better.

  • http://www.ropeofsilicon.com/profile/TheMovieGuru/ The Movie Guru

    Don't know if I can bring myself to watch this.