hot movie previews > Taken 2Anchorman: The Leg...The MasterPassionSkyfall
Categorized: Movie Reviews

Movie Review: The American (2010)

COMMENTS

Methodical, moody, emotional and excellent

Brad Brevet
By:
Published: Wednesday,

Thekla Reuten and George Clooney in The American
Photo: Focus Features

I already saw Roger Ebert has compared Anton Corbijn's The American to Jean-Pierre Melville's Le Samourai so I won't try to pass the thought off as an original, but it must be mentioned because the comparison is so appropriate. While George Clooney doesn't slide into his role in The American as skillfully as Alain Delon played Jef Costello in Samourai, the similar workmanlike and dedicated nature of the two characters is unmistakable.

The American, like Le Samourai isn't the modern day shoot 'em up actioner you expect when you hear the words "assassin film," instead it's more of a moody and methodical piece that never relies on action set pieces or explosions to raise the tension, but remains about as tense as it can get nonetheless.

'The American'
Review
Grade: A-

The American"The American" is a Focus Features release, directed by Anton Corbijn and is rated R for violence, sexual content and nudity. The running time is 1 hour 43 minutes.

The cast includes George Clooney, Paolo Bonacelli, Thekla Reuten, Violante Placido and Johan Leysen.

For more information on this film including pictures, trailers and a detailed synopsis choose from the following menu.

More About This Movie
Adapted by Rowan Joffe (writer/director of the upcoming Brighton Rock), the film is based on the Martin Booth novel "A Very Private Gentleman," a title that should give you a good indication of Clooney's character right off the bat as he plays the titular "American" at the film's core. Jack (Clooney), Edward or "Mr. Butterfly" depending on who he's talking to, is an assassin and master craftsman, though as skilled as he is we never get the impression he enjoys what he does.

"We do what we do best," he confesses to a kindly local priest (Paolo Bonacelli) as he's currently hiding in a small town in a remote mountain region outside of Rome, preparing for what he means to be his final job. The order has come down and he's met with a fellow tradesman (Thekla Reuten) who details the specifications for the rifle she needs built. Wary of everyone and looking around every corner after recently being attacked in Sweden, Jack trusts no one and his paranoia and equal dedication to his job keeps The American from merely simmering and instead warming to an outright boil.

However, while boiling with tension, The American never shies from its core emotion, the human need for companionship. Clooney adds another level to the film's already tense atmosphere by playing Jack with a sense of bewilderment and confusion. As in control as Jack is when he's working, he seems wholly unfamiliar with the emptiness he feels and the loneliness that comes with the profession he's chosen. It hits him hard in the film's opening scene and it becomes more evident as he comes to know a local prostitute (the often unnecessarily naked Violante Placido) in the process of trying to stay alive.

Dutch photographer and director Anton Corbijn is probably best known for his work as a music video director with the likes of U2 and Depeche Mode, but in 2007 he directed the little seen, but nevertheless great film Control based on the life of Joy Division frontman Ian Curtis. It was not only a great, evenly-paced feature debut, it was a beautiful film, and Corbijn's brought a similarly appealing photographic eye to The American.

Considering the film was shot in Italy you'd think it would be washed away in glowing sunsets over the Italian countryside. Instead it starts in snowy stark white terrain and then turns to the cold and grey cobblestones of a remote Italian village in the Apennine mountains. Only the amber glows of street lights met with occasional rain showers offer much color. Even when Corbijn decides to film in nature he relegates himself to a creek side you could find anywhere in the United States, let alone the remote corners of Italy.

These types of directorial decisions show Corbijn's dedication to character rather than an interest in merely dolling the film up with landscape inserts. Instead he chooses much more difficult shots, such as a shot featuring only the faces of Clooney (head on) and Bonacelli (in profile) as the they get into a discussion of sin that may be the best shot I have seen all year.

I have very few complaints about The American in general, though it seems the nudity could have been cut outright and the film would have achieved a PG-13 rating. I can't understand why some have said it is slow. Perhaps it's because Joffe's screenplay isn't overloaded with dialogue and needless exposition. Instead it's more cerebral and introspective. You won't hear me complaining about this.

Nearly every frame is filled with paranoid tension. Jack is searching for something, but you get the impression he's not sure what it is and even if he found it he might not trust what he finds.

In The American if there's a moment that isn't explicitly tense it's implicitly so, thanks not only to the nature of the story, but Corbijn's framing of the image. What's on screen in this film is just as important as what's not and getting into the mind of Jack is one of the hardest nuts to crack so far this year. I expect repeat viewings will prove beneficial and I hope to see it at least one more time before it ends what I expect will be a limited theatrical run.

GRADE: A-
If you enjoyed this post, help us out and share it on Facebook, Twitter or Google.

Join the conversation!

There are 26 comments so far. Scroll down to share your thoughts.

Links from Other Sites You May Like

Showing 26 Comments

  1. Alex

    It's very hight rating. Now I am interesting to see this

  2. Mari S

    A- really? Now I'm even more anxious to see this! I won't read your review before that though.

  3. Steve J

    I will note the other two reviews I have seen for this movie so far have been very average, so lower expectations.

  4. I haven't seen Le Samourai, but I really got a Jim Jarmusch vibe from the first trailer and that, along with Clooney and beautiful cinematography, really made me anxious to see this. I absolutely love moody, melancholic character dramas in this vein. Can't wait.

  5. m1

    Is this a hard-R? I'm thinking about taking someone to see it.

  6. maja

    Wasn't sure whether to watch this before, but will definately now. If it's half as good as Le Samourai then it's worth watching.

  7. Sean R

    I just came back from seeing it and I had high hopes because of your review but, I must say I wasn't blown away by it. It is a beautiful film, there is no doubt about that. However, the story got a little flustered at times and Clooney really didn't give his all, in my opinion. Films like Up In The Air and Three Kings had me hoping for an out of the ballpark performance but I was left with something a little less savory. Overall, I would give it a B-, borderline C+. It had some really great scenes, especially the ones with the priest, but that wasn't enough to distinguish it from being okay and great.

  8. You didn't find yourself wanting a bit more originality/unpredictability from the story? Because that is what keeps me from really raving about it.

  9. saw The Anerican tonite

    very good
    clooney very very good
    production very very very good
    2 women very very very very great lookers

  10. Dark Horse

    I watched it tonight and would characterize this as a European art house movie. A poetic type of film noir. Definitely not for a big audience. As to the nudity, I thought it was very functional. We needed to know that the prostitute was treated very 'fairly' in bed, not at all like a whore. Unaware of the director's nationality, I was stunned to walk out of the theater to the tune of Cuby and the Blizzard's 'Window of my eye'. Perfect ending to a perfect night at the movies.

  11. Central Ohio

    Can't wait

  12. Just spent good American money for one of the most boring movies that I've seen to date. In my opinion Clooney's name was used to draw a crowd for a very boring movie, there should be a way to get a refund for Defective movie's like this one !!

  13. Gerry Gallant

    This was the worst movie I've ever seen. A total waste of your time and money.I'm not sure how somebody could give this a rating of A- as my wife and I would rate it as a F

  14. WTB

    I just saw The American. Probably one of the worst movies I have ever seen. The American is awful. Nonsensical, stupid and vapid.

  15. Sandy D

    I acutally thought it was a joke at the end, but relalized no one was laughing like I was. After several great movies, I cannot believe he did this garbage…

  16. Robert

    I really didn't like this movie. I can watch slow paced movies with no problems, but this was too boring. Hardly any character development, very little story, and horrid pacing. Five people walked out of my screening, and listening to everyone leaving after wards, the general consensus was that it was too slow and uninteresting. Brad, if you liked it and give it an A- that's all good, but for me, I almost fell asleep during this movie and, being kind, can only give it a D.

  17. mfan

    This sound like what you might write if you wanted to write a positive review for Twilight.

  18. Sara

    I went to see the American last night. It was the most boring movie I ever seen!I want my money back! I can sit through a lot of slow movies but this was a joke! A lot of people left the screening half way through. Don't waste your time or money on this movie.

  19. Unbelieveable! And I paid $9 for this trash. Never saw a George Clooney movie before and will not be seeing another one. He shoots three people in the first 10 minutes, is running constantly after that and driving, driving, driving. But no explanation is ever given. What a waste of time. I even stayed to the end thinking something was going to happen!

  20. Nancy

    This movie was a waste of time and money.Had a hard time staying awake. And those of you that say we dont understand the art film, or have short attention spans…..get over yourselves. We understood this movie, it was a self glorifying,egotistical,embarassing display by George Clooney.Wanted to leave half way thru and my husband fell asleep twice. I go to the movies to be entertained,or to learn something…not to be abused.

  21. Feedback

    I just finished seeing this movie. It was okay. Not at all awful as some commenters stated, but not nearly as great as Brad states in the review.

    George had to force his charm down to zero which made his performance very awkward throughout the film while the relationship between his character and the priest seems to have been written just for the sake of having two or three lines of witty dialogue ("I don't think God has an interest in me, Father".) Other than that, the priest is hardly important to the story at all. Maybe at a symbolic or emotional perspective, but for the story, he does nothing.

    In fact, the story is pretty lame. He is a hitman that is going to retire so obviously he knows too much and his boss wants him dead. That isn't a spoiler, if you didn't figure this out after the second or third scene in the movie, then your deductive skills are lacking.

    I think the most underwhelming part of the story is its ending. Its ending does nothing for the whole film in general and doesn't really have a "POINT". Actually, not much of the movie has a point at all. Maybe it has a message, but not an original or interesting one. I recommend to pass on this film. C-

  22. D Taylor

    BORING! I did not watch the last 30 minutes and threw the DVD into the trash immediately after I ejected it. Clooney (and I am a fan) had the most annoying complacent look on his face the entire movie.

  23. Chris138

    Well, I guess I am in the minority here but I just watched it for the first time and loved it. As it was said in the review, very atmospheric and introspective, which I do not mind at all. I don't think many general audiences will embrace it much, though. Too bad.

  24. Monica Key

    I want the $1 back that I spent at Redbox. I started folding my laundry halfway through in order to stay awake.

~ PLEASE NOTE ~
If, in any way, your comment is an attack on the author of this post or a previous commenter, your comment will be deleted without question.

Add a New Comment

~ Movie Stills ~

The Great Gatsby
1 new still is now available
The Dark Knight Rises
13 new stills are now available

~ Trailers & Clips ~

Cannes Trailer
Trailer
Trailer
Cannes Trailer
Clip - "#1"
Trailer
Teaser Trailer
Teaser