Cannes Movie Review: Route Irish (2010)
My first introduction to Ken Loach is a good one
Photo: Wild Bunch
I had never seen a Ken Loach film prior to catching Route Irish, his last minute In Competition addition to the 63rd Cannes Film Festival. I had no real expectations, but was certainly curious to learn what all the fuss was about when it came to Loach and his work. However, I certainly didn't expect what I got, which was a highly approachable Iraq War story I could recommend to general audiences and one that takes a much different approach to the war than the majority of the films before it. It may be about Iraq, but it doesn't take place there and we aren't dealing with soldiers in the traditional sense. It's unique approach is what makes it worth watching, even if the story does falter a bit.
The cast includes Mark Womack, Andrea Lowe, Trevor Williams and Stephen Lord. For more information on this film including pictures, trailers and a detailed synopsis choose from the following menu.
Review
"Route Irish" was directed by Ken Loach and does not yet have a domestic distributor.
The absurdity of a privatized war and the ignorance society has for many that have died in Iraq jump to the head of the class when deciphering the message of Route Irish. One of the primary focus points here is "private contractors" or — as they are described in the press notes — private soldiers, Corporate warriors, security consultants and as the Iraqis refer to them, mercenaries. Route Irish sets its sights squarely on private military defense contractors making millions selling their services in Iraq with little concern for the destruction caused and the innocent lives lost. This is the story of two such contractors, one that has died for initially unknown reasons and another determined to find out what those reasons were and who's to blame.
Mark Womack as Fergus, makes his feature film debut and reminds me of something of a scrawnier Jason Statham with a bit more emotional presence. It's not a performance that will blow you away, but it works in a made-for-TV sense. Loach doesn't ask too much of Womack, although a drunken sexual encounter is a bit overdone as well as a second instance when Womack's character tortures a man. Neither moment comes off genuine.
Andrea Lowe playing Rachel, Frankie's girlfriend, is the film's other lead character. Her part of the story is purely emotional and hardly registers as a necessity to the overall narrative. Lowe is satisfactory in the role, but the sexual tension between her and Fergus isn't exactly believable, necessary or very well fleshed out. I was happy Loach didn't take things too far in these terms, but at the same time, a little bit was just enough for me to wish there had been none.
I don't know Loach's politics so I have no idea if there was an agenda here or not, but Route Irish is strong in its message and occasionally weak in its story. On top of being entertaining, I respect it for pointing out the atrocious nature of the privatized war taking place in Iraq, and the effect it has on those at home as much as it has on those on the battlefield.
However, I couldn't help but be fascinated by the irony of it all. Fergus was one of the contractors in Iraq making £10,000 a month, tax free for carrying out atrocities of his own. Yet here we are, in the audience, cheering him on as he searches for the story behind the murder of his friend. Alejandro Gonzalez Innaritu's Biutiful had a similar theme to its story, but it was more upfront about it. With Route Irish a lot of Fergus's behavior is masked by Hollywood style explosions and a fast paced storyline, whereas if you sit back and look it over, Fergus is no more righteous than the supposed "villains" of the film, he's just not as greedy about it.
Route Irish is played In Competition at the 63rd Cannes Film Festival and will be competing for the Palm d'Or.
Links from Other Sites You May Like
Showing 6 Comments
~ PLEASE NOTE ~
If, in any way, your comment is an attack on the author of this post or a previous commenter, your comment will be deleted without question.
Add a New Comment |
Click to Read Our Commenting Rules & Guidelines
Brad, to get a better idea of Loach's work you need to see the classic Kes; my favourite which is Land and Freedom, about a working-class Englishman's experiences in the International Brigade during the Spanish Civil War; Sweet Sixteen, which is set in contemporary Scotland; The Wind that Shakes the Barley, which is about the Irish civil war and won at Cannes a few years ago… and there are more.
You will find that several of Ken Loach's films (including Kes) have been released, officially & legally on YouTube in an admirable gesture by Sixteen Films, Ken Loach, Rebecca O'Brien & Paul Laverty.
Please note, however, that distributors have asked that some films be blocked in certain countries.
http://www.youtube.com/user/KenLoachFilms
Yeah, I considered including that link in my review. Also, was going to watch some of those while here in France, but, like you said… blocked.
I'll second the recommendation for "The Wind that Shakes the Barley". It's in the very small subgenre of decent Irish historical films.
You have to My Name is Joe, i think Peter Mullan won best actor at cannes for his portrayal of a recovering alocoholic. And Raining Stones has the most scary debt collector in cinema history!
Ladybird, Ladybird is also a very good film. My favorite Loach film is Land and Freedom.