Movie Reviews

'Maniac' (2013) Movie Review

What a piece of junk

Maniac movie review
Elijah Wood in Maniac
Photo: IFC Films

I haven't seen William Lustig's original film from which director Franck Khalfoun's Maniac is based. Apparently it's a cult classic, but I hadn't heard of it until this remake/reimagining came around, but from what I've read the chief difference between the two is Khalfoun's attempt at a first person narrative. Whoop-dee-woo!

Grade: D

Maniac"Maniac" is a IFC Midnight release, directed by . This film has not yet been rated by the MPAA. The running time is .

The cast includes , and .

For more information on this film including pictures, trailers and a detailed synopsis .

The name of the man whose life we will be living is Frank (Elijah Wood). You see, Frank's mom was a whore that liked to have threesomes at home and sex on the sidewalk in downtown Los Angeles. Frank looked on, but was eventually asked to go wait for her in the car. You know, because he might get cold. Anyway, he grew up with some issues.

Frank now runs Angela's Mannequins where he restores mannequins and dresses them up with the bloody scalps of the women he kills whilst trundling around Los Angeles. Yes, Frank is a serial killer. A serial killer with mommy issues so it's really deep territory we're getting into here.

After killing a couple of girls early on, Frank notices someone snapping photos outside his shop. He raises the metal gate and we meet Anna (Nora Arnezeder), a chatty little photographer with a love of mannequins... if you can believe that. They get to chatting and we get such back-and-forth witty banter as Frank asking if her accent is French to which she replies, "Oui, you have a good ear." Good ear? It's a French accent, not Klingon.

The whole film plays like this, which is to say it feels 100% fake. You know the online video sex chat rooms you see in movies? It feels like that. For example, one girl Frank meets invites him back to her apartment where she starts rattling off a series of unnatural dialogue read with absolutely zero inflection, ruining any measure of reality. "Want me to put on some music? I love this song, dance with me. I wanted to slip into something a little more comfortable. Wanna touch 'em? Your hands are warm. Squeeze 'em." If the screen had cut to black and asked me to put in another dollar it would have seemed more natural than anything that takes place in this movie.

It also doesn't help that not only are we seeing the film through Frank's eyes, but he speaks out loud as if the audience is too stupid to comprehend what's going on. Maniac would have played better as a nearly silent film rather than have us watch Frank as he sex chats with a woman online and reads back to us what he's typing.

Further along, Frank chases women through empty Los Angeles streets while battling with his migraines and childhood flashbacks and it's a complete waste of time. Okay, maybe not a complete waste of time, it has some great makeup effects.

Frank is scalping women left and right and the film's finale is a splatter house of gore and it is some truly impressive work. Unfortunately, the attempt to put the audience in the place of the killer and really allow these gruesome moments to take hold is lost as a result of attempting to put is in the place of a stereotypical psychotic killer, rather than someone any of us may be able to connect with.

If we're going to do this POV gimmick, I would have preferred almost a Falling Down-type scenario, but dialed back quite a bit. Someone we could imagine ourselves being. We go to Starbucks and the grocery store. We take a shower, eat dinner and watch some television. However, over the course of the film the character would be faced with the moments from all of our lives that annoy us and suddenly the character finds themselves on edge, pushed to the limit and ultimately deciding to do what they would normally consider morally wrong.

Give the audience a chance to contemplate or at least debate the justification of what's going on rather than just have us watch as the lead character slices a woman's scalp off and looks in a mirror for the one hundredth time.

In fact, there's a moment in the film where Frank and Anne go to the movies and it got me thinking how great it would have been to end the movie in a movie theater given the above scenario. We see him purchase his ticket, walk through the doors, buy a popcorn and enter the theater. He searches for a seat, sits down and suddenly looks around realizing everyone in the audience has blank faces, much like his mannequins. Essentially to say Frank is all of us as much as he is none of us. Cut to black, roll credits. That, to me, would have been something to talk about. This movie is best left forgotten.

Thanks for Reading! Join the Community!
Support the Site! Make it Faster! No Ads!

Your support goes a long way in ensuring stays stable. For less than the price of one small popcorn, you can can help support RopeofSilicon and, in turn, visit the site every day without ads! Including this one!

Subscribe Now!

More Movie Reviews

'The Lazarus Effect' (2015) Movie ReviewD

The Lazarus Effect (2015)

'Focus' (2015) Movie ReviewD+

Focus (2015)

'Everly' (2015) Movie ReviewC-

Everly (2015)

'My Life Directed By Nicolas Winding Refn' (2015) Movie ReviewB+

My Life Directed By Nicolas Winding Refn (2015)

Click to Browse Even More Reviews
  • Ryguy815

    Well crap..I had high hopes for this.

  • Lukas Mix

    Yo, Here in Europe it's already on DVD. I had the pretty much the same issues as Brad did until I switched it off after 20 minutes of stilted boredom. Have no desire to catch the finale.


  • maja

    I saw this a few months ago when it was in theatres in the UK. I too had never seen the original and I thought the way in which the film was shot was pretty cool...the problem is that they kept repeating the same tricks (looking in mirror) so it became tiresome quickly.

  • deerhunter

    I've seen, and am a very big fan of, the 1980 original. It's a slasher, gory classic. With an appeal I still can't pinpoint. Was it the strange, genuine perf NY character actor Joe Spinnel gave?

    I am not seeing this "remake." From the looks of it, it looks horrible.

    I recommend the original. See it. Tell me what you think of the eerie, violent scene on the beach with the two lovers in the car.

  • Hamza Zain

    I had the exact same issues with the movie. The dialogue felt odd and forced, not even remotely natural. Also, how incredibly gory it got took me right out of it. Overall just not a good movie.

  • Dim McRemnant

    I'm a huge fan of the original. It was a classic slasher film from 1980. I was waiting for this for a long time so I had high expectations. Honestly, the movie did not disappoint for me.

    I see what you mean in some ways, Brad, but I felt that the first person parts of the film were outstanding. It definitely brought me into the film, made me feel like I was there and that I was going to get caught with Frank at any moment. I thought the entire film was completely effective.

  • Xarnis

    Saw this today and thought is was complete trash. I gave it a D-

  • Joseph Bridges

    It's too bad you havnt seen the original. It's very creepy on so many levels. If you go into it with a "Midnight Special" mentality, it can be a lot of fun.

  • Peggy Adams

    Learn how to profit using Google. You can monetize your time spent online, while you are surfing, and make a nice extra income with this search engine giant! Earning potential up to $20000 monthly! Details can be found at

  • danishwonder danishwonder

    I disagree with all the people who don't like this movie. I thought it was very good. I especially liked how the soundtrack created a lot of tension, with a sort of electronic pumping sound. I also though the actors were good in it and well chosen for their roles.