'The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo' (2011) Review
The feel bad movie of Christmas lives up to its slogan
Photo: Columbia Pictures
Dubbed "the feel bad movie of Christmas," David Fincher's The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo lives up to its slogan and its very hard R-rating with a rape scene uncomfortable enough to make you wonder how the MPAA let them slide without cutting more, revenge for that rape that will leave you equally chilled and the dull slap of a golf club to the face that sends teeth rattling to the floor. Fincher has undoubtedly embraced the dark and bleak nature of Stieg Larsson's novel and now it depends on whether or not you are ready to endure what he's put together for you, though I dare you not to be absolutely entranced by Rooney Mara as the film's titular character.
The cast includes Rooney Mara, Daniel Craig, Stellan Skarsgård, Robin Wright, Joely Richardson, Steven Berkoff, David Dencik, Christopher Plummer, Yorick van Wageningen, Goran Visnjic, Alan Dale and Joel Kinnaman. For more information on this film including pictures, trailers and a detailed synopsis choose from the following menu.
Review
"The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo" is a Columbia Pictures release, directed by David Fincher and is rated R for brutal violent content including rape and torture, strong sexuality, graphic nudity, and language. The running time is 2 hours 38 minutes.
Wasting little time in making clear his intentions, Fincher briefly introduces the audience to the aging Swedish industrial businessman Henrik Vanger (Christopher Plummer). Having just received another pressed flower on his birthday, a reminder presumed to have been sent by whoever killed his niece 40 years earlier, Henrik realizes he can no longer allow her memory or her killer to torment him like this. He hangs up the phone and the music shifts into something of a Nine Inch Nails interpretation of a James Bond title sequence. Carbon fiber imagery begins dripping as oily hands crush soft, anonymous faces and dragons spew fire in a plastic cacophony energized by an industrial remix of Led Zeppelin's "Immigrant Song". It's entirely out of place, but if it's your kind of thing, as it is mine, it certainly gets you in the mood to watch a movie.
As the title imagery fades we are introduced to recently disgraced journalist and editor at Millennium Magazine, Mikael Blomkvist (Daniel Craig). Blomkvist has just seen his name dragged through the mud thanks to an article he wrote that he later learns was fueled by a bogus source, allowing a dirty businessman to gain the upper hand and sue him for libel. In an attempt to ensure the magazine doesn't go down with him, he fires himself, a decision that's met with another opportunity.
Henrik Vanger's determination to find his niece's killer before the torment kills him is too much to bear. For forty years he's essentially tried all on his own and now he looks to Blomkvist, a man with plenty of time, nothing to lose and a soft spot Vanger knows he can use to his advantage. Being a businessman in the area for many years, Vanger not only promises Blomkvist payment no matter what he finds, but information that will allow him to finally nail the dirty businessman that eluded him. Blomkvist accepts and the journey begins.
The circumstances under which they meet are changed from the source material, but soon entering into the picture is Lisbeth Salander (Mara), the titular "girl with the dragon tattoo", a descriptor that is more cosmetic than anything else as Salander's character is hardly determined by her tattoos or the punk rock clothes on her back (though I absolutely loved a t-shirt she's seen wearing more than once that reads "F**k You You F**king F**k"). Lisbeth's story is more complex than material things and in the first of Larsson's trilogy of stories, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo is the least revealing.
When it comes to Lisbeth, this story introduces us to what she has become rather than where she comes from. We know she's been assigned a guardian, we know she's a hacker and we know she trusts no one. These three traits weigh heavily on her involvement in the story as she soon comes to be Blomkvist's assistant in the search for the killer and their relationship becomes the underlying focal point of the film.
Having read the first two books in the Millennium trilogy and seen the three previous Swedish adaptations, the one thing that has always bothered me about this introductory story is how unimportant the mystery of the missing person is and yet how much time is devoted to it (though I'm sure others would argue it's pivotal when exploring Lisbeth's character). Unfortunately, there isn't any way of getting around this, but Fincher and Zaillian do their best to make sure the unique relationship between Lisbeth and Mikael is what the audience walks away thinking about, especially since the mystery of the missing girl is handled with a quick and simple stroke. Rightfully so if you ask me, as the final 15 minutes of this film are what truly won me over more than anything that came before them.
I give a large part of the credit to this film's success to Mara who opens herself up in every way to Lisbeth and, just as importantly, has the perfect look for the character. At once ferocious, determined and sometimes frightening, Mara also gives Lisbeth a sense of fragility. In an instant she can be made to look almost like a child, adding a tremendous weight to the actions seen on screen.
Circumstances make Lisbeth an easy character to sympathize with, but a few choice moments such as when she asks, "Can I kill him?" and a longing glance in the snowy distance sum up the character more than any piece of clothing, piercing or tattoo. This isn't to disrespect costume designer Trish Summerville's efforts or the makeup department who softened up Mara with pale white skin, smooth features and jet black hair offering contradictions that seemingly capture different meaning with each changing glance. All of this aided the overall effect the character had, though I was fond of the fact Fincher captured the idea this was Lisbeth's story as much as the Coen brothers realized True Grit was Mattie's.
Adding to the atmosphere, Fincher has again brought in The Social Network composers Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross for the score, giving it a seething electronic vibe and one that is certainly more present and, at times, noticeable than it was with Social Network. Early on especially, there are moments when there is too much music layered over the feature and too many noises that have little to nothing to do with what's on screen, but in most instances it is a perfect complement to the tortured and tormented plot.
Boiled down, this would appear to be the best adaptation of Larsson's source material you could come to. In my opinion the story has always lacked focus, placing too much emphasis on the mystery rather than an evolving exploration of the title character. Fincher and Zaillian seem to understand that and have done their best with the story they had and, I hope, have created an opportunity for them to explore the more intriguing second book in the series, "The Girl Who Played with Fire," where Lisbeth's story truly begins to take shape.
I find it hard to picture Fincher directing a three-film franchise, but if there was ever one that suits his style and would benefit from his sensibilities it's this one. While this film didn't completely blow me away I find myself longing to watch it again, which I will the first chance I get.
Links from Other Sites You May Like
Showing 16 Comments
~ PLEASE NOTE ~
If, in any way, your comment is an attack on the author of this post or a previous commenter, your comment will be deleted without question.
Add a New Comment |
Click to Read Our Commenting Rules & Guidelines
Does this mean you will be moving Rooney Mara up on the Best Actress roster? Looks like other reviews are highly positive about her as well.
Interesting….Since you have reviewed this one as a stand-alone movie without comparing it to the earlier adaption (maybe intentionally) , i would want to know how does it stack up to the Swedish version which was decent, if not great, and how does Mara fare as compared to Noomi Rapace ….
And any word on Craig ?…
I would still watch it though but want to know your views on these …..
2 Hours and 38 minutes?? Looks like Fincher DID have to give in to Columbia and cut down his cut from 3 hours. I'm glad it's still as good as we wanted it to be
Ok so awhile back it was officially announced that the ending was changed. W magazine said "the ending—the resolution of the drama—has been completely changed. This may be sacrilege to some, but Zaillian has improved on Larsson—the script’s ending is more interesting."
So, if you've seen the Swedish films and read the book, you didn't have any quarrel with this? Was it that apparent?
Brad, Just a couple of questions…was Mara's performance better than Rapace's? and whose version of the character was better for you?
I'll probably see this, but NOT during Christmas.
Thought the exact same thing.
I quite liked the fact that Brad DIDN'T compare this movie with the Swedish version (I know he doesn't like the Swedish one and he's not impressed by Noomi Rapace's performance).
I fint it interesting how we disagree on our opinion about the books. I find the Harriet Vanger mystery very puzzling – it reminds me a lot of Agatha Christie – and I don't like the second book as much as the first. There are three words that describe the second book for me: Not. Enough. Lisbeth.
Sounds fantastic to me.
Hello from Sweden!
The first Swedish reviews from our big papers have just been published and they are all positive. In fact, all reviews I have read so far give the film a "4" on a scale up to 5. I'm opening up to the fact that maybe Mara's performance is even better than Noomi's. I'm eager to watch it and I already hope Mara will star in two more films.
I'm envious that someone has already seen the Fincher movie as I have to wait another week to see it! He's the perfect director for this material. The swedish adaptation was competent but nothing special.
The swedish versions of the 2nd and 3rd parts were so bad, was it the films or the source material?
I liked it, Mara was electric- simply terrific. It still needed to shave 20 to 30 minutes of running time. It would have been a much better film at 2 hrs. It just feels too long at 2 hr 35 minutes.
Just saw it today. I liked it, but def. not one of Fincher's best. I know it's staying loyal to the book and all, but I question how beneficial the 15-20 minute master of disguise epilogue really was, and even some of the parallel story-telling in the beginning.
Mind you, I understand they have a franchise in mind and are trying to set up the following two instalments, but should doing so come at the expense of this film?
Also, I didn't take too much to Mara's performance. I felt that she def. grew on me as the film went on, but I always felt she was rather removed from it all – which I guess is sort of the point, but I never found her to be all that interesting… And for a character that the film is named after… well… I thought Craig as Blomkvist was far more interesting and engaging.
Just saw it last night. Really enjoyed it, up there with Drive and The Ides of March as one of the year's best. I totally agree, however, about the story lacking focus. The mystery was intriguing and it was pivotal to gaining a broader understanding of Lisbeth, but it just seemed a little bit inconsequential in the end (I should make clear, I have not yet seen the Swedish adaptations, nor have I read the source material). Nevertheless, the acting was excellent, especially on Mara's part, the cinematography and score were chilling, the atmosphere was fantastic, the tension tangible, and the style unique – I was won over instantly by those opening credits.
I didn't necessarily find Craig's character incredibly interesting in and of himself, but I think that's the point. He's an every man, a stark contrast to Lisbeth's strangeness, which made their relationship all the more fascinating.
All in all, definitely one to check out if you're able to sit through it (that rape scene… wow).
Didin´t like it. Mara had a weird monotonous voice, swedish accent don´t sound like that at all. She played Salander almost fragile, Rapace did her…sharper. Fincher missed the flower drama, the revenge scene, the "she saw her killer" scen, the bedtime scenes, the car that blow up. Even the Bjurman scenes was better in the Swedish adaption, he was moore creepier. FincherBjurman looked like a highschool teacher, bad enough though but not creepy. FincherTGWTDT looked "more" though, the train, the cold somehow. The only thing I liked better in the Fincher film was the ending.