Comments on: 'X-Men: First Class' Goes All 'Gossip Girl'

By: Sentinel King

Sentinel King — Sun, 02 Aug 2009 02:58:28 +0000

I didnt have a problem with the first 3 x-men movies but the third kinda confused me. I wasn't a close follower of X-men and didn't really know that much about it aside from the fact that the Juggernaut was Professor X's brother, and some other things like Scott being…..on that note..now i have a problem with the third movie..i didn't even go see the Wolverine Origins..I wish there was a way that they could SOMEHOW start the x-men movie saga over entirely..they could do SO much better. I would love to see a great movie again. its been so long =/

By: Kimmie

Kimmie — Sat, 18 Apr 2009 04:50:03 +0000

i agree with -rattler76 first post , wolverine and angel should not be in this new movie, they came in way after all the others were in the school, so to have angel and wolverine in the new x-men is really stupid and then it makes you very very confused, and it would really ruin the whole series and then x-men will go down the drain like c.s.i (newer version without grisom) like honestly people don't know x-men any more D:<

By: i-am-right

i-am-right — Wed, 07 Jan 2009 02:39:37 +0000

@rattler76: what they should do is NOT have it connected to the past three movies and maybe look at a perfectly good storyline all laid out for them already. what kind of fanboy are you exactly to say angel should not be in this? He's kinda like oh, one of the main characters, one of the first in the x-men team. Are you only a "marvel fanboy" through the movies? screw what the movies did, if they have the nerve to NOT make Colossus Russian then i say they should just stop what they were doing in the mess that was X-3 and instead of this downward spiral, rewind back to a story's origin, IN ITS COMIC. it would be the best thing for this franchise to follow the comic closer. I feel better now.

By: queenbee

queenbee — Thu, 18 Dec 2008 02:37:11 +0000

well, i think it'll be fine. josh does chuck which is kind of nerdy. he'll be able to pull this off. and i most definitely don't think he's gonna turn this into a gossip girl or the o.c. episode. he'll do fine. i'm assuming he's not THAT stupid to eff up x-men… just let it go. he'll do well. ^_^

By: Phobia

Phobia — Thu, 20 Nov 2008 00:40:31 +0000

I am a Marvel fangirl, and all I have to say is,

God Damn Fox.

By: Adam

Adam — Wed, 19 Nov 2008 13:07:22 +0000

I actually think Josh Schwartz is a really good choice just based on the TV work he's done. And he's done action (or, at least, I'm presuming it's action…). He's the creator of the series "Chuck" on NBC, which, although I've never watched it, I'm betting it has action in it as a spy show.
But Schwartz has definitley cornered the teen drama market, and I won't lie: he's good. While The OC and Gossip Girl may be soapy, they are fun, dramatic, and just all around very good. He's a good writer. He'll be able to handle the high school stuff really, really well. Yah, X-Men seems like an odd pairing, but, still. I like it.

By: rattler76

rattler76 — Wed, 19 Nov 2008 12:13:03 +0000

Sorry but when it comes to Marvel I am a bit of a fanboy. So here we go:

X-First class should not have Wolverine or Angel in it. Wolverine was added to the x-men in the first movie long after Cyclops, Jean Grey and Storm were students and Angel didn't come into play until the third movie.
In the books the first x-men were Angel, Beast, Cyclops, Iceman and Jean Grey.
Other early members are Colossus, who is only a student in the films just like Iceman and Nightcrawler who's introduced in X2.
I'm curious to see how they make Fist class consistent with the movies not using Wolverine for instance.
It would be a mistake to suddenly follow the comics more closely after changing things for the other movies.

I found it a shame they didn't hint at the past relationship between Victor Creed (Sabretooth) and Wolverine in the first movie allready. It could've added more mistery to Wolverine's past.

A teen drama writer? Doesn't sound to good allright.
It has allways been Marvel's strength that their hero's were people with feelings and emotions but you need the all out action as well.
Perhaps if he co-wrote with a different writer.