Filed under: Movie News

Why Do People Want an 'Arrested Development' Film?

Is what you've got never enough?

Photo: Fox Television

Talk of a feature film adaptation of the canceled Fox television series "Arrested Development" just will not go away, and each time it is the nugget of news offered up is so small it is hardly worthy of mention. However, I think enough has happened recently for me to at least ask why everyone is so interested.

Sure, I liked the show, but it ran its course and I can't imagine a feature film adaptation actually being successful. "Arrested Development" was an acquired taste if there ever was one. It was a show that required the audience to be patient and allow the comedy to grow with each week. This is why the show was soon funny, the longer you stuck with it the more you got to know the characters, and the funnier their antics became. The show got to be so funny in fact they had to cancel it.

Now we have Ron Howard telling MAXIM in the video to the right talking how promising the whole idea is except they need one thing… a script. The Hollywood Reporter added a similar sentiment today saying the film looks like it may land at Fox Searchlight with Mitch Hurwitz writing and directing. We already know the cast wants to do it as we have often heard quotes from Jason Bateman, Will Arnett and Jeffrey Tambor talking about how either they would like to do the film or that they have actually heard it is a go.

Tambor was most recently quoted saying:

"Well no, because we're doing it. We are going. It's a go. I actually just this week talked to Mitch Hurwitz, so we're doing it. When the writer calls you, and the director, and the executive producer calls you, it's a pretty good sign."

I am not writing this article saying they shouldn't make the movie, but I am wondering if they do make the movie who is going to go see it? Most often shows that get canceled are canceled because they can't find an audience or the studio doesn't know how to market the film to bring the audience in. The show won a Golden Globe, an Art Directors Guild for excellence and two Emmys and yet they couldn't get anyone to watch it. Perhaps San Francisco Gate's TV columnist Tim Goodman had it correct back in 2004 when he asked "'The Wire' and 'Arrested Development' — too smart to make it?" In the article he says the two shows couldn't be anymore different, but they shared one trait, "relatively speaking, nobody's watching either of them."

While "The Wire" managed to eek out five seasons to the joy and satisfaction of several fans, "Arrested Development" managed only two and a miniscule third season to end it all. Perhaps the difference lies with HBO as they didn't give up on their series, but even "Arrested Development" eyed the cable route and failed to secure a proposed 12 episode deal with Showtime. Is the show poison or did it just boil down to ratings alone as David Cross told Jimmy Kimmel way back when that he isn't surprised Fox ditched the show considering the ratings reality shows bring in and said, "I hope Fox puts in its place, like, you know, America's Cutest Retards. What's left for them to do? We got midgets trying to pull an elephant. What's left? We've got orphans trying to figure out who their dads are…come on. Let's go with retards. OK? Let's do it."

Of course, the film adaptation does have one thing going for it, a growing and vocal fanbase. If Twilight taught us anything it's that the louder you are the more people pay attention, even if you are screaming incoherently. On top of online fervor even MSNBC's Keith Olbermann took time out from screaming about Republicans to talk about the potential for an "Arrested Development" movie. While I know an Olbermann endorsement is like getting a birthday party invite from the most annoying person in the world, but it's TV and the battle needs to begin somewhere.

I have attached the Olbermann clip below along with a funny rant from David Cross giving his reasoning as to why the show was canceled.

Thanks to FilmDrunk for pointing out the MAXIM vid.


Click Here to add an
Avatar to Your Account
Post #1
Gravatar

With respect, I generally disagree with this article's thrust. Im in the UK and the show is always held up as the paragon of American comedy. I think the fanbase is pretty damn massive and I'm also sure the writers and cast are smart enough to make it a true, hysterical comedy, which is accessible to a new viewer while remaining true to the characters and humour. Can't wait to see this and I think it will do surprisingly well at the box office.

/new fan, as of four months ago.

- Tom
( November 21st, 2008 | 6:32 pm )
Reply to this comment
Post #2
Gravatar

That David Cross clip was awesome!

- Justin
( November 22nd, 2008 | 5:03 am )
Reply to this comment
Post #3
Gravatar

Take a look at the pic above the fold. Now imagine being the Fox exec that pulled the short straw and has to somehow renegotiate contracts for season 4. Bateman and Cera are getting sent feature scripts, Arnett's signing v/o contracts, deRossi's half goddess, and the rest of the cast's agents know that AD isn't AD without their client. And I can only imagine what kind of license fee Howard and Co demanded.

The truth is Fox gave this show 53 eps to find an audience that was actually willing to turn on a TV Sunday night (then Monday, then Friday… they didn't try Wednesday though; I bet the show would have been a hit if they gave it a shot at Wednesday). Nobody watched, at least not enough to justify the rising above the line costs. Think about this, 53 episodes is more than double the entire series of Extras and The Office (UK) combined!

The movie will open, regardless of script and timing, simply because all of the fans that only watched the show after borrowing someone else's DVDs might actually put some money down for a movie ticket.

- GregM
( November 22nd, 2008 | 10:27 am )
Reply to this comment
Post #4
Gravatar

While part of me really wishes this wasn't the case, it's true, and there's evidence. Firefly was a major cult hit as well. The fans clamoured about it so much that eventually Serenity was made. The fans massively supported the movie, all secretly (as nobody wanted to jinx it) hoping the movie's success would lead to the show being picked up again. The movie failed to find much of an audience beyond the diehards, did poorly, and has left everyone involved feeling doubtful of anything else coming from it. A comedy has slightly more potential than a sci-fi western (or western sci-fi?) for crossover appeal, but it faces the same problems.

I enjoyed Serenity and will enjoy an AD film if it is made. I just don't know how many other people will.

- Christopher Scarr
( November 22nd, 2008 | 10:43 am )
Reply to this comment
Post #5
Gravatar

I would generally agree with the thought process behind this article. How could a TV show that failed to not only survive it's original home on Fox, but fail to be picked up on Showtime, make it on the main screen?

That said, a lot has happened since the cancelation of the show. Michael Cerra has been a huge success on the big screen. He's a hot ticket with the younger audience. Will Arnett has had several successful movies since AD was canceled – he'll bring the Frat Boy audience. And Jason Bateman has also seen success since AD – he'll bring the middle-aged audience that has watched him grow up from his teens.

I think with a movie, you'll see a lot of new interest in AD. When the TV show was on, not many people knew who the cast was – although, loyal followers were very familiar. Now that those 3 have seen great success in movies, I think a whole new audience will be curious what all the fuss was about. Who knows, a successful movie could spawn a revival of the show on Showtime or HBO…where it belongs. A major network was not the right place for this show.

- Mike
( November 24th, 2008 | 12:40 pm )
Reply to this comment
~ PLEASE NOTE ~
If, in any way, your comment is an attack on the author of this post or a previous commenter, your comment will be deleted without question.
Leave Your Feedback
(required)
(will not be shown) (required)
DON'T WANT YOUR COMMENT DELETED?
Click to Read Our Commenting Rules & Guidelines
Follow Us On Twitter!
RSS Email
Latest Posts
Latest Video
Nine ~ TV Spot
New Pictures
Friend RopeofSilicon on Netflix!