Comments on: 'Twilight' Series Halted, Read Stephenie Meyer's 'Midnight Sun' Draft

By: Maja

Maja — Wed, 25 Nov 2009 15:44:01 +0000

I am sorry that the book was stolen, but i do hope that ypu will continue writing since i am a big fan of your work :)

By: Olivia Rebis

Olivia Rebis — Sun, 22 Nov 2009 14:58:38 +0000

I love your books so much!The person who published your book must have something wrong with him or her!His or her life will be ruined whenever everyone finds out who did it!I am not reading the book online cause i want to read the hole thing in one because oncei finish one of the twilight books i almost go deprest.I love the book so much!

By: CeLeste

CeLeste — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 00:08:44 +0000

PLEASE DONT DO THIS TO THE READERS AND THE WRITERS YOU HAVE INSPIRED I NEVER THOUGHT OF BEING A WRITER TELL AFTER THE FIRST BOOK SHE WROTE WAS AMAZING, THEN MY HEART WENT HISTATIC WHEN I FOUND OUT THERE WAS A WHOLE SAGA. PLEASE FINISH THE BOOK PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

By: Princess Tink

Princess Tink — Wed, 18 Nov 2009 20:28:35 +0000

i wanted to know if she will let us read the book midnight sun on the internet

By: Jessica

Jessica — Sat, 14 Nov 2009 20:05:36 +0000

I think that she should still write the book all the way and release for those who are still interested in it. If you have no more desire to read this book than I think you should keep your comments to yourself and try not to ruin it for the rest of who are still hoping it will come out.

So Stephanie please finish your book(:

By: Claudia

Claudia — Tue, 03 Nov 2009 23:06:12 +0000

Good God, she's STILL moping about and refusing to write the book? How pathetic and childish. I doubt I'll even read it though; I'm bored with Twilight anyway.

By: Rose

Rose — Tue, 03 Nov 2009 14:46:57 +0000

@Taylor: In June of 2008 she said it was her next project but no timeline was set, then in august of 2008 she announced the illegal distribution of the partial draft and said she is not going to finish it. So with no updates on the matter since August of 2008, we're all still led to believe that she will not be finishing the book, which is very depressing. I read the partial draft (the legal way) on her website and it is amazing. I really hope she has a change of heart and finishes the book.

By: Meghan Hillier

Meghan Hillier — Mon, 12 Oct 2009 02:00:23 +0000

Stephanie I Know You Are Very Upset With Those People And I Would Be To,But I Haven't Read Midnight Sun Yet But I Really Hope That You Will Continue Writing Me And My Friend's LOVE Your Writing Your A Genuis !My Life Hasen't Been A Bucket Of Roses Either Latley !But That Doesn't Mean That Im Going To Give And I Hope You Won't Either !=)

By: Chelsea

Chelsea — Sun, 11 Oct 2009 15:30:17 +0000

I cant believe that she quit writing the book just because it leaked on the internet. It happens all the time. Its not as big of a deal as she makes it seem. Sure, I can understand taking a few days or weeks off to cool down about it and then finish writing. She is going to loose fans quick. Unless she finishes writing, She is going to loose several fans and the respect of the people who trusted her to be loyal to her books. I dont mean this as direspectful in anyway. Its just an opinion of what I think.Please dont take it the wrong way.I feel bad that someone did that to her.If I where her it would hurt my self-esteem if someone did that to me. So I can understand how bad it would hurt her. I feel as if I need to read more. I think its a good Idea to put the first few chapters before it comes out so people can get a good sense of what is coming. It will help readers want to read it more.I absolutely love the twilight Series and I really wish she would finish it.Her mistake was trusting someone that was not fit to be trusted. So I am asking,no begging Stephanie Meyer to finish the last book! Please.Thanks for listening.

By: JMDon Ald

JMDon Ald — Sat, 26 Sep 2009 10:12:57 +0000

No wonder Bella is written as such a drama queen…no mystery there. I wish Stephanie Meyers would just finish the book and end the histrionics. It's regrettable that someone trespassed on her rights and took control of her property…but she can't seriously think she's an exclusive victim to this type of piracy. At least it's still her work and the credit remains hers. Besides the exposure only gained a larger fan base for the book…Twilight fan appetites for the book have been whetted…it seems the thief only managed to provide
free advertisment for her product. The work may have been rough draft, but surely she
doesn't consider readers clueless enough to not know that most works are created from rough drafts…who pens a finished product at first attempt? It seems a little pompous and ingracious to penalize your readers and fans who have been faithful to your work and made
her family wealthy. How about a little appreciation and consideration for that base and a little less dramatics. Get over it….protect your future work more closely and finish the book. I know I for certain will not spend another dime or minute reading anything else written by an author who has so much contempt and so little consideration for her readers. Until this book is finished I will not read any thing else written by Stephanie Meyers

By: Abigail

Abigail — Fri, 18 Sep 2009 09:51:49 +0000

@Isabelle: Very true... :)

By: Abigail

Abigail — Fri, 18 Sep 2009 09:50:15 +0000

Well, for my perspective… I think Stephenie Meyer should continue with "Midnight Sun" and stop felling sorry for herself! Its ridiculous… So her story got leak… She should take that as an inducement for her to try harder! And if she doesn't want to continue… She could go along with the sequences of "Breaking Dawn" because for my perspective I think it's not finish… She could see this in "twilight saga" website (it's something like "friendster" or "facebook") at the discussion of "Twilight Novel" that lots of people think that it's still not finish.
So. Stephenie, move on and continue with the sequences of "Breaking Dawn" then if you've got to the last book (The Happily Ever After) then continue with "Midnight Sun"… :)
Coz, as I said… "Breaking Dawn" isn't finish yet… :)

By: Isabelle

Isabelle — Tue, 01 Sep 2009 20:34:13 +0000

@Taylor: Not true… The comment that says this was actually posted before everything happened :( it was actually posted in june 2008 she would write it… and in august that the illegal copy was on the net.. (or is there an even newer post?) I really hope she continues writing it too, Edward is more interesting than Bella ^^ and actually all the books could change completely from his view, he just does so many strange things…

By: Luvey

Luvey — Thu, 27 Aug 2009 20:56:45 +0000

Dalfiuss, Midnight Sun IS Twilight indeed, but written from a different sight.
Its not stealing money from everyone that buys it.
Everyone is free to buy, or not buy that book ( if it would be published ).

But, since Edward is away from Bella most of the time ( or so she thinks ), he has a totally different story.
It really is different.
At the end, its the same.
Just another telling.

Lots of people get Edward wrong, stephenie said.
She wanted to explain him.
Tháts why she wrote te book.
No other reasons involded I believe.

And Shay, i don't agree with the.. "breaking dawn best book ever"
I mean.. all it goes about is Bella, getting pregnant. and then its about The Volturi.
They all belive they're going to die.
All the 4 books we're heading this way, to the big fight with the Volturi.
And all that ever happends is a conversation.

I found that very dissapointing.

I'm writing a 5th book myself. Just for me, to really end it :)

and for so far… i hope Stephenie will find the will to complete the book.
I'd love to read it <3

By: jennifer

jennifer — Thu, 27 Aug 2009 01:57:00 +0000

Stephanie Meyer is old enough to know that no matter how much you think you can trust someone, it doesn't always hold true. She gave out copies of the draft, she took a chance. I don't believe that just because 1 person put midnight sun on the internet her MILLIONS of fans should be denied the chance to read the book in it's entirety. I'm truly sorry this happened to her, I think it is very wrong. However, Now that all her fans have had a chance to read the partial draft, I don't think it's right to hold it back. Edward is a character that has become very dear to people. We've been told of this book being told in his perspective. We've read just enough to get our hopes up. If she refuses to finish it, she will be letting a lot of people down when it was only 1 person in the beginning who let her down.

By: momof3boys

momof3boys — Sat, 15 Aug 2009 22:55:28 +0000

This is the only time were the movie is better than the book. After seeing "Twilight" I ran out and got the other three books and read them. I have never been so disappointed. I hope she is done writing. Thank god she had nothing to do w/ the screen play.

By: hannah lappin

hannah lappin — Sat, 15 Aug 2009 12:49:02 +0000

it would be an amazing book looking at it from edwards pointview.it would just make people love the story even more ………………………………….please write it …… but im not forcing you to its your choice :D

By: hannah lappin

hannah lappin — Sat, 15 Aug 2009 12:41:04 +0000

please stephanie write midnight sun.people have really grown to love edward and bella.you have to write it.

By: Aviee

Aviee — Thu, 06 Aug 2009 01:18:36 +0000

i totally agree with that!

By: Victoria

Victoria — Tue, 04 Aug 2009 17:47:58 +0000

Let's say she dosent finish it. I think personally that would be selfish of her because she has billions and billions and BILLIONS of fans (I'm a fan myself) but she kinda needs to get over it becasue millions of her fans watn to read midnight sun and she said all this stuff how she dosen't feel the same writing it. Then why did she tell people she was writing a perspective of edwards view I mean yeah shes telling people about her new book. But she probable forgotten her fans that WANT to read it. I mean millions of movies get pirated and songs get taken without rights. How would those singers feel or the movie producer feel when they get there sstuff taken with out rights!

By: -Sydddd`

-Sydddd` — Fri, 31 Jul 2009 03:13:51 +0000

@miki: wow..ur rite…i mean…shit happens n wen it duz..u gotta get over it!! shes bein a baby….ppl get screwed over..get over it Stephanie…

By: Avieee

Avieee — Thu, 30 Jul 2009 19:00:02 +0000

I agree i mean why would any 1 wannna post up stephanies draft wiithout permission, it was just a draft, but i must say the draft was awesome!!!!!!! I just hope that stephenie cools down and decides to make the boook…If she dosent then the person who put the draft on wrecked it for allll of us who wants to read it…

By: Shay

Shay — Sat, 25 Jul 2009 17:37:28 +0000

All of the boos were AWESOME! Twilight, was good, but it was also just the begining, so it wasnt the best to me, but it was enough to get me to read the othr books. New Moon, was… different, it was good, and made mekeep turning pages, I loved it. Eclipse, it seemed like it didnt realy have a meaning to me 'cause nothing super big happened in it but it did tell you how things wre going to be between Bella and Jake, so otherwise it was fantisitc, oh and it showed who Bella was goig to be with (Edward)!!!!! Now, Breakin Dawn, it was above all the best book I have ever read, it told what Bellas human life was like being married to Edward was liike and then Jake told how much pain he was in while Bella was carrying Renesmee, he thought tha he was loseing everything he wasnted, then, Bella tells her story again about what it is like to be a vampire, mother, and a wife. then after her first hunt she finds out that Jake the boy who used to love her only love her because Renesmee was part of her even befor Bella got pregnat , Bella got mad and hated Jake but then later found out that Renesmee was untouchable because Jake had imprinted on her.
Again, all of the books were great. I hope thatStephaine Meyer will fiish Midnight Sun, and then wrtes the other books from Edwards point of view.

To Stephine: Please finish writing Midnght Sun, Then if you can please write the other books in Edwards perspective. We (your fans) love your books and hope and plea that you will finsh the best novels tha has ever been writen about vampires. We NEED and WANT those books. Please please please please please pleasssssse finish those books??????????????????

Whoever posted Midnight Sun on the internet without Stephines aprovle is a BITCH!!!!!!!!!!!! bitch! bitch! bitch! bitch! bitch!

By: montgomeryk

montgomeryk — Sat, 18 Jul 2009 15:10:48 +0000

Same here! 4 days to read it. My husband and children were considering locking me up in the funny farm. They did not understand the obsession and I did not realize they could not function without my attention for longer than 15 minutes.

By: Holli

Holli — Wed, 24 Jun 2009 23:43:05 +0000

I agree, it is pretty depressing about Midnight sun and I would so love her to start writing it again. This was my first time reading the partial draft via her website and I love reading it from Edward's perspective.

By: gabby

gabby — Tue, 23 Jun 2009 04:01:23 +0000

I really want Stephenie to finish Midnight Sun. I havent read the draft posted on the internet, trying to stay loyal to Stephanie Meyer, but I want to read the book so much. I think she should finish the book for all her fans, and try to move on from the leak. I know a book is always better in its last version, and that Stephanie didnt want people to read Midnight Sun before it was published, but she could start the book over, change it a lot, and make as great as all the other books. But it is her choice, and whatever her choice is, is the one i want to respect

By: Celina

Celina — Fri, 19 Jun 2009 10:41:00 +0000

@Claudia: I completely agree. Every estrogen filled teenager in my school is literally OBSESSED. They never stopped talking about it. And apparently all of them are going to marry Robert Pattinson, the Jacob guy, the Emmett guy, and the Jonas brothers -_-. So they basically want a reverse harem. I even overheard one girl saying she prays to Stephenie Meyer to finish Midnightsun. Not to god for Meyer to finish it. She prays TO Stephenie Meyer! o.O sometimes I worry people will start a religion. Is it true that some girls cut there throats with their nails when they saw Robert Pattinson come out somewhere!? Well they'll commit suicide when they find out he's doing a move called "little ashes" which is rated R for the gay scene that happens between him and some other guy while they're naked in a lake.

By: Maureen van Staden

Maureen van Staden — Fri, 19 Jun 2009 06:39:50 +0000

Ive read all 4 books and it was great.I watch twilight the movie every day.im a huge fan of twilight and cant wait to see the 3 next movies. I would really love to get the book midnight sun and read it.I just hope at the end of the story that bella and edwart will be together forever because they make a great couple in the movie and personally. So please finish the book midnight sun that I can buy the book.I read all 4 books in one week.at work the whole day in the evenings until about 2 in the mornings.Great work Stephenie.

By: Claudia

Claudia — Thu, 18 Jun 2009 17:34:43 +0000

Here here! *raises fist in air* I so agree!

By: Celina

Celina — Wed, 17 Jun 2009 20:33:15 +0000

OMG soooo many comments. I've read a few and I can understand the many different points of view there are. Although I find some of the responses to Stephenie's threat of just quiting midnightsun more intresting than the books themselves, I think I remember reading somewhere that she wanted to continue midnightsun in 2 years or something. I think she said that she wanted to do it when everyone has already forgot about it because she only likes to write when she feels alone. So apparently she doesnt feel alone when everyone is talking about it. When I read that I really had a wtf? moment. I mean, i get where she's coming from (if that was even really her words- the website said it was from her interview?) But u know, I was kinda ed. I don't want to wait 2 years to read something that i'm excited about now. I mean, i like the twilight series but i'm not obsessed with it. Her books are fun to read but I know they aren't classics. I wish she would continue it and hopefully get over the whole issue but if she doesn't, well, there are plenty of vampire books in the world. And like some said, many people will be satisfied with fanfictions. I would personaly prefer to read the real thing or not at all but that's just me. What I do definetly agree with and dislike about Stephenie Meyer is that she was naive to just hand out copies of her draft to people she barely knew. I know she gave at least one to that director of the twilight movie and Robert Pattinson. I guess I don't know if she spent loads of time with them or not but even if they weren't the ones who leaked it ( since she gave out others too but only she knows which one was leaked and who leaked it and she wont tell who that was) it still seems she was a little too trustworthy. Well, i guess she doesnt care about us that much. She's ed at the people who read her thing ileagally and shes ed at the rest of us for presuring her too much. I'm was angry at the people who read it too and started this crap but honestly if i had found her draft (before she put it "legally" on her site) I would have read it too. So now I put blame on the person who leaked it in the first place. But apparently it doesnt matter since she ignores all of the people who put up desperate pleas for her to finish it -_-. So I feel less respect for her. Regardless of anything else it IS her responseibilty to finish that book. For the sake of the fans, her title as an author, and for her characters. Maybe i'm getting a little too noble here but i wanna read the rest damn it! But guess she just has to get over it and hopefully she will either finish it or at least make a definite anouncement that she wont and not just keep dragging people along panting for it.